I read a goal.com article recently slating that if James Milner is being signed, Carrick will be ousted out of the squad..
I wonder what does most people here thinks?

I wont argue that Carrick's having a bad bad patch at the moment. I still think he had a good season. His form at the beginning of the year was good after sitting out a few early games and SAF mentioned that Carrick usually gets better as the season starts to warm up.

Michael Carrick vs James Milner.

Now this is what I want to ask. If United want to buy Milner but in the process will lose Carrick let's say for a cash + swap deal, would you do the deal? And if you say yes, why?

My answer is no. But this is coming from someone who idolize Carrick as his favorite United player, so it's best that I hear it from the public.

(All these doesnt matter about Hargreaves or Anderson, though both have not given what Carrick have gave to United as of yet)